Could Fabian Hurzeler Replace Michael Carrick at Manchester United?

Winless Run Increases Pressure at Old Trafford

Manchester United’s winless streak has reached five games in all competitions after a 2-0 defeat to Atletico Madrid in the Champions League. The result has intensified scrutiny on Michael Carrick, who is yet to recreate the form that marked the end of last season in his first campaign as permanent manager.

Why Hurzeler Is on the Shortlist

According to The Sun, United have quietly begun planning for life after Carrick, with Brighton’s Fabian Hurzeler identified as a leading candidate. The 33-year-old has built a reputation for aggressive, fluid, possession-based football, and Brighton have been among the Premier League’s most entertaining sides over the past year. His former club St. Pauli also saw a strong all-round profile, combining attacking intent with pressing and structural discipline.

Brighton Unlikely to Sell Mid-Season

Even if United were prepared to pay a compensation fee, Brighton are expected to resist. The Seagulls are chasing European qualification, and losing their head coach mid-campaign would threaten those ambitions. An approach before the summer looks improbable.

Interim Option or Conte Return?

Should United act before the season ends, an interim appointment appears more realistic. Antonio Conte is also free and could start immediately, offering a ready-made alternative.

Next up is a Premier League meeting with Leeds United, where United will be chasing only their second league win of the campaign.

Our Take

Hurzeler would be a bold, forward-thinking appointment, but timing is everything. Sacking Carrick this early risks looking reactive, and a summer move for a coach with a clear identity makes far more sense than a hurried mid-season gamble. Conte brings experience, yet his demanding style may not suit a long-term project.